How Much Does Car Insurance Go Up After an Accident

August 11, 2024

Auto Insurance

How Much Does Car Insurance Go Up After an Accident?

Car insurance rates usually increase after an accident. According to a study by US News, drivers with a single accident on their record see their rates go up by about $872 per year. The national average rate for these drivers is $2940 per year, compared to $2068 for those with a clean driving record.  
 
However, car insurance rates can vary based on many factors including location, insurance provider, and driving history. That’s why it is common for our clients from different states to ask, “How much does car insurance go up after an accident?”. 
 
Today, in this article, we’ll discuss how car insurance rates increase after an accident, distinguish between at-fault and no-fault scenarios, and analyze state-by-state rate changes. We’ll also talk about factors affecting premiums, steps to take post-accident, accident forgiveness, and tactics to reduce insurance costs after a claim. 

Difference Between at-Fault and No-Fault Accident

To put it plainly, an at-fault accident is a situation where you’re responsible for causing the crash. This means your insurance company will likely pay for the damages, and your car insurance rate might go up. 
 
A non-fault accident, on the other hand, is when you’re not to be accused of the crash. In this situation, the other driver’s insurance usually covers the damage. 
 
In some states, there are no-fault insurance laws which means each driver’s insurance pays for their own damages, no matter who caused the accident. These laws are designed to speed up claims and reduce lawsuits. However, even if you’re not at fault, your insurance rates still might increase because insurers consider that you’re more likely to have future accidents. 

Here is a list of no-fault insurance states: 

  • Florida
  • Hawaii
  • Kansas
  • Kentucky
  • Massachusetts
  • Michigan
  • Minnesota
  • New Jersey
  • New York
  • North Dakota
  • Pennsylvania
  • Utah

Drivers of these 12 states are required to purchase no-fault or PIP coverage insurance. As these laws are subject to change, it is important to speak with a local insurance agent to make sure the type of coverage your state requires.

How Your Car Insurance Rate Is Affected by an Accident 

This is quite simple! Car insurance premiums are often calculated based on risks. When you have a car accident your auto insurance rate normally goes up. This increase depends on several factors, including the severity of the accident and who was at fault. If you’re found at fault, your car insurance can go up significantly by 20% to 50%. 
 
This happens because the insurance company sees you as a higher risk after an accident. So, they raise the price. For instance, if your yearly car insurance cost was $1000, after an accident, it might go up to $1200 or more. However, if you have accident forgiveness, your car insurance rate might not increase for the first accident. 
 
In essence, how much your car insurance goes up after an accident depends on the details of the incident and your specific insurance policy. 

How Much Does Insurance Go Up After You’re at fault in an Accident?

When you’re at fault in an accident, your insurance rates typically go up. The increase can vary based on several factors. If it’s your first accident, some insurance companies may offer you accident forgiveness. This means your rate might not go up right away. 
 
However, for subsequent accidents, the increase can be significant. Factors like the severity of the accident, the amount of the claim, and your driving history all play a role in deciding the price hike. According to Bankrate, on average, there’s a 42% difference in rates before and after an accident. This increase applies to both full coverage and minimum coverage policies. 
 
It should be noted as well that your location and the insurance company you’re with can affect how much your rate increases. So, we recommend reviewing your policy and understanding how accidents impact your insurance premiums. If you’re still concerned about rates, you can learn defensive driving courses or switch to a different insurance provider. 
 

How Much Does Car Insurance Go Up After an Accident: Rates by State  

Car insurance rates can vary notably from state to state, and this includes how much they increase after an accident. As a driver, you should understand these differences. Below is a state-by-state analysis of how car insurance rates typically go up after an accident (Via MarketWatch): 

 State 

Clean Driving Record  

Single Accident 

Rate Increase (%) 

California 

$2313 

$4085 

77% 

Michigan 

$3,643 

$5,204 

43% 

Alabama 

$1,775 

$2,498 

41% 

Alaska 

$1,685 

$2,248 

33% 

Arkansas 

$2,038 

$3,001 

47% 

Arizona 

$2,008 

$2,938 

46% 

Colorado 

$2,173 

$3,040 

40% 

Connecticut 

$1,919 

$2,699 

41% 

Washington D.C. 

$2,218 

$3,235 

46% 

Delaware 

$2,881 

$3,893 

35% 

Florida 

$3,244 

$4,608 

42% 

Georgia 

$1,973 

$2,931 

49% 

Hawaii 

$1,656 

$2,306 

39% 

Idaho 

$1,402 

$2,057 

47% 

Illinois 

$1,541 

$2,193 

42% 

Indiana 

$1,587 

$2,333 

47% 

Lowa 

$1,563 

$2,086 

33% 

Kansas 

$1,918 

$2,924 

52% 

Kentucky 

$2,522 

$3,655 

45% 

Louisiana 

$3,040 

$4,423 

45% 

Massachusetts 

$2,430 

$4,043 

66% 

Maryland 

$1,833 

$2,958 

61% 

Maine 

$1,238 

$1,796 

45% 

Minnesota 

$1,766 

$2,528 

43% 

Missouri 

$2,104  

$2,992  

42% 

Mississippi 

$1,658 

$2,603 

57% 

Montana 

$1,979  

$2,848  

44% 

Nebraska 

$1,871 

$2,679  

43% 

Nevada 

$2,788 

$4,112 

47% 

New Hampshire 

$1,362 

$2,088 

53% 

New Jersey 

$2,513 

$4,127 

64% 

New Mexico 

$1,943 

$2,720 

40% 

New York 

$2,088 

$2,863 

37% 

North Carolina 

$1,627 

$2,756 

69% 

North Dakota 

$1,916 

$2,431 

27% 

Ohio 

$1,599 

$2,341 

46% 

Oklahoma 

$2,278 

$3,066 

35% 

Oregon   

$1,925 

$2,945  

53% 

Pennsylvania 

$1,981  

$2,820  

42% 

Rhode Island 

$2,357 

$2,605 

11% 

South Carolina 

$1,845 

$2,496 

35% 

South Dakota 

$2,291 

$3,300 

44% 

Tennessee 

$1,524 

$2,227  

46% 

Texas 

$2,205 

$3,365  

53% 

Utah 

$1,928 

$2,855  

48% 

Vermont 

$1,199  

$1,722  

44% 

Virginia 

$1,781 

$2,636  

48% 

Washington 

$1,616  

$2,320 

44% 

Wisconsin 

$1,694  

$2,516  

49% 

West Virginia 

$2,177 

$3,195 

47% 

Wyoming 

$1,702 

$2,305 

35% 

Note: The above data is taken from MarketWatch.

How Long Does an Accident Last on Your Record? 

According to Investopedia, an accident typically stays on your driving record for 3 to 5 years. The exact duration can vary depending on state laws and insurance company policies. 
 
For instance, in Michigan, points from the accident remain on your driver’s license for 2 years. Conviction related to the accident stays on your record for at least 7 years (Via Michigan Auto Law). 
 
In California, it remains for 3 years from the date of the accident. In New York, 3 years from the end of the accident year. In New Hampshire and Oregon, an accident stays on your record for at least 5 years. 
 
During this period, your insurance premiums may increase as it reflects the additional risk. This is often due to claim history and the impact on the conscious pool of drivers. Once the accident is removed from your record, your car insurance rates may decrease if no further incident occurs. Always check with the local DMV (Department of Motor Vehicle) and insurance provider for specific details. 
 
If Accident Occurs, Learn How to Find Out If Someone Has Auto Insurance

What Factors Can Impact My Premiums After a Claim?  

Auto insurance is mandatory in most states in the United States. That’s why many policyholders often want to know the factors that can influence car insurance premiums after a claim. Here are some factors: 

  1. Fault: If you’re at fault in an accident, your rates typically go higher. You can explore affordable full-coverage auto insurance rates with L.A. Insurance.
  2. Claim Severity: Higher claims result in larger premium increases.
  3. Driving Record: A clean driving record may reduce the impact, but multiple claims do the opposite.
  4. Location: Premiums can vary by state and city due to different risks and regulations. For instance, Florida is one of the most expensive states for car insurance.
  5. Conscious Pool: Insurance companies may consider the risk level of your pool of drivers when setting rates.
  6. Policy Type: Full coverage generally sees higher increases than minimum coverage.
  7. Age and Experience: Younger, less experienced drivers often face larger price hikes. 

Can I Prevent My Car Insurance Rate from Increasing After an Accident? 

Yes, you can certainly take some steps to prevent your car insurance rate from increasing after an accident. One option is to ask about accident forgiveness, which some insurance companies offer. This can prevent your first at-fault accident from affecting your insurance premiums. 
 
Maintaining a clean driving record and practicing safe driving can also help. Plus, completing a defensive driving course is another initiative you can take to prevent car insurance rates. This also might qualify you for a discount. 
 
Besides, to avoid any complications, you should report the accident promptly and cooperate fully with your insurer. Also, you could consider raising your deductibles to lower your premium. Lastly, you should always compare quotes from multiple insurers to find the best rate. You can also find an agent from L.A. Insurance. Our affordable insurance agency offers the cheapest rate for full-coverage car insurance policy.
 
TL; DR: 

  • Ask your insurer about accident forgiveness
  • Maintain a clean driving record
  • Take a defensive driving course
  • Report the accident promptly
  • Consider paying a higher deductible
  • Shop around for the best rates 

Pro Tips: Take as little risk as possible and be a responsible driver to manage your insurance costs successfully. 

What Is Accident Forgiveness and How Can It Help? 

We have already mentioned the term “Accident Forgiveness”. But what is it, exactly? How does it help to prevent your car insurance premium from going up after an accident? Simply put, it’s a feature some car insurance companies offer. It can prevent your premium from increasing after your first at-fault accident. 
 
With Accident Forgiveness, the insurer “forgives” the accident. This means they don’t just count it against your driving record. As a result, your insurance rate stays the same. You’ll usually need a clean driving record to qualify for this feature. However, some insurance providers might offer this automatically. Others might charge extra for it. 
 
You can save money and feel more financially secure by taking the benefits of this feature. Without it, an accident could lead to a large premium increase. By preventing this, you can manage your car insurance costs better. Ask your insurer if they offer Accident Forgiveness!

How Do I Lower My Insurance Cost After an Accident? 

If you need to claim on your auto policy, you might have questions about how to lower insurance costs after an accident. Here’s a simplified breakdown: 

  1. Switch Insurers: Consider changing to a different insurance company to find the potentially cheaper auto insurance price. According to many experts, you could save money by doing this, especially after an accident.
  2. Update Your Coverage: Adjust the limits and terms of your auto insurance policy. For instance, increasing your deductible can help reduce your monthly payments. However, you should make sure not to lower your coverage too much.
  3. Take a Driving Course: Completing a defensive driving or driver education course may qualify you for discounts from your insurer, especially if you’re a young or older driver.
  4. Ask About Forgiveness: Ask your insurer about accident forgiveness programs. If you qualify, you can lower your car insurance rates.
  5. Improve Your Credit Score: Working on improving your credit score by paying bills on time and reducing debt can lead to lower insurance premiums.
  6. Look for Discounts: Many insurance companies offer discounts for safe driving memberships in certain organizations, vehicle safety features, and more. Make sure to explore all the available discounts.
  7. Shop Around: Compare car insurance rates from multiple insurance companies to find the cheapest rate. As each insurer has its own way of calculating premiums, you might find affordable options elsewhere. 

The Bottom Line

After an accident, car insurance rates typically rise. On average, the increase can be significant, often around 42%. However, the actual amount varies based on factors like the severity of the accident, your driving history, and the car insurance company’s policies. As a policyholder, you need to be aware of the potential increase and explore options like shopping around for better rates or seeking forgiveness programs. 

Frequently Asked Questions 

1. Will My Car Insurance Rate Increase If I’m Not at Fault for the Accident?

Ans: Yes, your car insurance rate can still go up even if you’re not at fault for the accident. Auto insurance companies may raise rates because you’re now seen as a higher risk. However, some vehicle insurance providers might offer accident forgiveness programs that can assist you in managing insurance costs effectively. 

2. What Happens to Insurance Policy If I am Caught Driving Under the Influence (DUI)? 

Ans: If you’re caught driving under the influence of any drugs or alcohol, your insurance provider may put you DUI offender list and consider you as a high-risk driver. Therefore, they can also charge you higher rates for your car insurance policy. 

3. How Does Property Damage Affect My Insurance Policy?

Ans: Property damage can increase your insurance policy premiums. When you file a claim for property damage, it signals to your insurer that you’re at a high risk, potentially leading to higher rates. 

4. How Much Does Insurance Increase After a Claim?

Ans: Car insurance typically increases by 20-50% after a claim. It also potentially cancels out any no-claims discounts, even with protection, premiums may rise because no-claim discounts represent a reduction from the base premium.

5. How Much Does Car Insurance Go Up After Two Accidents?

Ans: You’ll see a significant increase in auto insurance premiums after multiple accidents. The exact rates can depend on many factors including the insurance company, location, and driving history. Multiple accidents signal higher risk to insurers which ultimately result in substantial premium hikes.

 

Sources: 
 
1. Van Keuren, M., & Yao, S. (2024, April 22). How much does insurance go up after an accident? US News & World Report. https://www.usnews.com/insurance/auto/car-insurance-increase-accident 

2. Kim, G. (2024, April 1). How much will my car insurance go up after an accident? Bankrate. https://www.bankrate.com/insurance/car/rates-after-an-accident/ 

3. Robinson, D. (2024, March 16). How much does insurance increase after an accident? https://www.marketwatch.com/guides/insurance-services/how-much-does-insurance-increase-after-an-accident/ 

4. Boyte-White, C. (2024, March 8). How long does an accident stay on your record? Investopedia. https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/091815/does-your-car-insurance-company-report-accidents-dmv.asp 

5. Michigan Auto Law - Auto Accident Attorneys. (2024, February 15). What happens in a No-Fault accident, who pays? Michigan Auto Law. https://www.michiganautolaw.com/car-accident-lawyer/faqs/what-happens-no-fault-accident/ 


 

Tag :

cheap car insurance

car maintenance

Comercial Auto

Latest Blog

About Us

LA Insurance can find the best insurance policy for your needs, with low down payments and affordable coverage

Icon Alt
Icon Alt
Linked In

Our Products

Copyright © LA Insurance

(Built by Neutrix | Powered by Neutrix Systems)