Auto Insurance Deductible Explained

“Auto insurance deductible” sounds a bit technical, right? But it’s not that complicated. In fact, it’s a simple concept that can save or cost you a lot of money, depending on how well you understand it.

In this guide, we’ll explain everything clearly for you.

You’ll learn what a car insurance deductible means, how it works, when you pay it, when you don’t, and how to pick the best deductible based on your budget and driving habits. We’ll even walk you through real-life examples, pros and cons, and practical tips for 2025 and more.

What Is Car Insurance Deductible?

Let’s start with a simple definition of an auto insurance deductible. It’s the amount you pay out of pocket after an accident or covered event. When you buy an insurance coverage for your vehicle, you get to choose your own deductible. The amount you choose needs to be paid first during the claim process, and after that insurer will reimburse you.

Let’s say your vehicle needs $2,000 in repairs. If your automobile insurance deductible is $500, you’ll pay that first. The insurance company pays the remaining $1,500 only after your share is covered.

This amount applies to certain parts of your car insurance policy, like collision or comprehensive coverage. And it does not apply to liability insurance, which covers damage or injury you cause to others.

In short, the deductible is your share of financial risk under your insurance contract. It’s a core part of how auto insurance works, splitting responsibility between you and your insurance provider. And it will reset with every claim you file.

Need affordable full coverage auto insurance with low deductible amount? Then pick your deductible amount for collision and comprehensive insurance and request an auto insurance quote today from L.A. Insurance.

Types of Deductibles on Auto Insurance

There are two main types of auto insurance deductibles:

• Collision Deductible
• Comprehensive Deductible 
  
• Let’s explain them here for you

  Collision Deductible

• This deductible is applicable for collision insurance coverage. It’s not a mandatory coverage unless your vehicle is financed.
• It applies when your car hits something like another vehicle, a wall, a tree, or another stationary or moving object. And it pays for the repair cost of your vehicle regardless of fault.
• Now, if you’re in a car crash, your vehicle is damaged, and you file a claim under collision insurance, you need to pay the collision deductible first.
• For example, if your car repair costs $3,000 and your collision deductible is $1,000, your insurance company pays $2,000. It's that simple.
• $500 is the most popular collision deductible. Depending on your driving risks, driver’s profile, car’s value, potential repair costs, and budget, you should choose your deductible for collision insurance. Your insurer may give you the option to choose from $0, $250, $500, and $1,000 deductibles.

More>> What Is Collision Insurance?

Comprehensive Deductible

• This covers non-crash events and the incidents out of your control such as theft, fire, vandalism, natural disasters, and animal collision (e.g., hitting a deer).
• Let’s say a storm shatters your windshield. In that case, your comprehensive deductible applies, not collision.
• If the cost to replace it is $800 and the comprehensive deductible amount is $250, you simply $250 first. And the rest is covered by your insurance company.
• Like collision, comprehensive coverage is optional but might be required for financed or leased vehicles. Besides, it’s worth carrying if your car’s value is still very high.
• Both collision and comprehensive deductibles are chosen separately. You can mix and match based on your needs. Some drivers usually pick a low comprehensive deductible and a high collision deductible, or vice versa.
• It's also important to note that other coverage, such as personal injury protection (PIP) or uninsured motorist property damage (UMPD), may also have deductibles in some states.
• Liability insurance, however, never has a deductible. It only pays others when you’re at fault.

More>> What Is Comprehensive Car Insurance?

How Does an Auto Insurance Deductible Work?

• A deductible for auto insurance is your share of the cost before your insurance covers the rest. And it applies each time you file an insurance claim. It’s not like a health insurance deductible you pay annually.
• Say your car insurance policy includes both collision and comprehensive coverage, you’ll have two separate deductibles. So, each time there’s an incident like a crash or a hailstorm, you pay your chosen deductible amount first.
• And only then does your auto insurance coverage kick in to pay the remaining damages. This deductible is sometimes paid directly to the repair shop or subtracted from your claim settlement.

For example:

• You hit a pole. If you file a claim under collision coverage, your collision deductible applies.

A tree falls on your parked car. That’s a comprehensive deductible situation.   
Apart from collision and comprehensive, some policies may have optional add-ons like:

• Vanishing deductible: Reduces over time with safe driving.
• Full glass coverage: Covers windshield replacement with no deductible.
• Collision deductible waiver (CDW): Waives your deductible if the other driver is at fault.

Real-World Example of Auto Insurance Deductible Application

Jenifer, a 28-year-old graphic designer, owns a mid-size sedan and is trying to reduce her monthly auto insurance premiums. Her current deductible is $500, but her monthly premium feels steep. After reading a Reddit thread, she considers raising her deductible to $1000 to save money, especially since she has an emergency fund that could cover it if needed.

So, Jenifer contacts her insurance company and learns that increasing her deductible to $1000 would lower her monthly premium by about $25. However, her car is under loan financing, and the loan agreement doesn’t allow deductibles higher than $1000. So she can’t go beyond that. She checks her savings and feels confident she can afford a $1000 out-of-pocket payment if necessary.

Jenifer raises her deductible from $500 to $1000. A few months later, she gets into a minor fender bender. The repair costs are about $2200. She pays the $1000 deductible, and her insurance covers the rest. Because she didn’t file previous small claims, her insurer doesn’t penalize her or drop her. She learns the value of keeping claims for significant expenses and having the deductible savings ready.

Key Takeaways:

• Raise your deductible only to the amount you’re prepared to pay out-of-pocket.
• Check if your car loan agreement puts a cap on your deductible.
• Avoid filing claims for small incidents to keep your policy active and affordable.
• An emergency fund can make higher deductibles manageable and reduce monthly costs.

Looking for a reliable insurance provider for car insurance? Whether you’re in Michigan, Colorado, Texas, or other states, reach out to L.A. Insurance. We’re your local insurance provider, most known for our affordability and extensive coverage. Dial us at (800) 893-9393 or talk to an insurance agent near you.

When Do I Have to Pay the Deductible for Car Insurance?

Short answer: You pay your deductible whenever you file a claim for damage covered under collision, comprehensive, or certain other coverages.

This clearly means that you don’t always pay your deductible for car insurance. But when you do, it’s tied to specific insurance coverage types. So, you’ll pay your deductible if:

• You’re at fault in an accident and file under collision coverage.
• Your vehicle is damaged by vandalism, theft, fire, or natural disasters (under comprehensive coverage)
• You apply for glass damage under comprehensive windshield coverage
• Another driver hit and ran after damaging your vehicle
• You make a PIP claim or use uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage in some states

Situations When You Don’t Need to Pay a Deductible

You don’t always have to pay your auto insurance deductible. Sometimes, your insurance policy or the situation itself spares your wallet. Here are the key situations where no deductible may apply:

You’re Not At Fault

If the other driver is 100% at fault and their liability auto insurance covers the damage, you won’t pay your deductible. In some cases, your insurance company may pay upfront and recover the cost later, including your deductible through subrogation.

You have a Vanishing Deductible

Some insurance companies offer a vanishing deductible program. If you’re a part of this program, with every year of safe driving, your deductible decreases and may possibly go down to $0. So, if you’ve built up enough credits, your next insurance claim could be fully covered without you paying a dime.

You Claim Involves Only Glass Damage

If you have full glass coverage, you don’t need to pay the comprehensive deductible for windshield repairs or replacement. In some states, including Florida, Kentucky, and South Carolina, insurers are legally required to waive the deductible for glass-only claims.

Collision Deductible Waiver Applies

A collision deductible waiver (CDW) can kick in if you’re hit by an uninsured driver and not at fault. It prevents you from paying your collision deductible, depending on your state laws and policy terms.

The Repair Cost Is Lower Than Your Deductible

If your vehicle damage is less than your deductible amount, the insurance company pays nothing, and neither do you. But you won’t need to file a claim either. You just pay the small amount out of pocket.

Deductible Was Waived by a Mechanic

In rare cases, a repair shop may offer to waive your deductible as a promotion or payment plan. But be careful. While it’s legal, it can’t involve insurance fraud or overcharging your insurance company.

In the end, we want to remind you again that the deductible is tied to your coverage, mostly. And if you’re applying through any of the following coverage, you don’t need to pay the deductible:

• Liability insurance
• Medical Payment Coverage (MedPay)
• Bodily Injury (BI)
• Property Damage Liability (PD)
• Roadside Assistance
• Rental Car Reimbursement

Average Cost of Auto Insurance Deductible

Most auto insurance deductibles fall between $250 and $2000. The most common amount? $500. It’s the sweet spot for many drivers balancing monthly cost and out-of-pocket risk.

For collision coverage, drivers typically choose $500 or $1,000. Some go higher to lower their car insurance rate.

And comprehensive deductibles are often lower compared to collision insurance. It’s typically around $250 to $500 since repairs like windshield or theft tend to cost less.

Some insurers offer $0 deductible options for glass-only claims or as a part of vanishing deductible programs.

However, the best car insurance deductible is subjective and depends on your budget. Ask yourself:

• “Could I comfortably pay this tomorrow if my car got hit today?”

If not, it’s too high, no matter how much it saves on your insurance premium.

How to Choose the Right Deductible for Auto Insurance in 2025: 7 Easy Steps

Every individual is different, and so are their needs for car insurance coverage and deductible amounts. Choosing the right deductible requires evaluating which amount best suits your personal situation. For example, if you drive a high-value vehicle and have sufficient savings to cover expensive repair costs, opting for a higher deductible on both collision and comprehensive coverage can be a smart decision. This approach typically results in lower monthly insurance premiums.

Here are 7 easy steps to help determine the best car insurance deductible for any driver:

Step 1: Know What a Deductible Does

Your deductible is the amount you pay before your insurance starts covering you. A higher deductible means you will pay a lower car insurance rate. A lower deductible means you will face less financial risk after an accident.

Step 2: Assess Your Risk Level

Drive in high-traffic, high-crime, or storm-prone areas? You're more likely to file an insurance claim. If yes, lean toward a lower deductible.

Step 3: Check Your Emergency Fund

Can you pay $1,000+ without wrecking your budget? If not, don’t risk a high deductible. Choose something realistic. But if you’re confident that you can afford more than $1,000 upfront payment, you can surely choose a higher deductible and enjoy a lower car insurance rate.

Step 4: Know Your Vehicle’s Value

Older cars? A big deductible might cost more than the car is worth.  If your vehicle is worth under $3,000, consider skipping comprehensive or collision coverage altogether.

Step 5: Compare Deductible Options

Use an auto insurance deductible calculator or quote tool. See how changing the deductible affects your insurance premium. If you see that a high deductible amount doesn’t save you much, then it’d be wise to choose a lower deductible.

Step 6: Read the Fine Print

Some insurance policies include perks like vanishing deductible, CDW, or glass coverage with no deductible. Understand what your policy includes. If you have one of these facilities, you can enjoy driving with more financial safety and confidence.

Step 7: Customize by Coverage Type

Choose different deductibles for collision and comprehensive insurance. Mix and match based on what risks matter most to you. For example, if you’re a safe driver living in a flood-prone area, you should be more focused on picking a comprehensive deductible amount compared to a collision deductible.

How Does Deductible Impact Car Insurance Premium?

Your deductible and your car insurance premium work like a seesaw. The higher your deductible, the lower your monthly or annual car insurance rate. The lower your deductible, the more you’ll pay in premiums, but less when filing a claim.

That’s because you’re shifting more financial risk onto yourself and less onto the insurance company. Let’s look at how different deductible amounts can affect your insurance costs:

Average Premium Based on Deductible:

Source: Bankrate | As of July 2025

More>> How to Lower Car Insurance Rate?

How to Avoid Paying a Car Insurance Deductible

You don’t always have to pay your deductible right away. Some insurance policies don’t require upfront payment. Instead, you might see it subtracted from your claim payout.

If your repair shop is flexible, ask if they offer payment plans or can delay collecting the deductible. While not common, a few will work with you, especially if you’re a returning customer.

In rare cases, mechanics may waive your deductible. It’s not standard practice and could raise compliance concerns. So don’t push if they say no.

If you don’t have the cash, consider waiting to file the claim until you’ve saved up or arrange a small loan to cover your share.

Above all, compare shops. Some are more accommodating than others when it comes to deductibles, repairs, and billing timing.

More>> What to Do If You Can’t Afford Car Insurance?

FAQs Related to Auto Insurance Deductible

Can I change my vehicle insurance deductible anytime?

Yes, you can change it anytime by contacting your insurance company. However, most people do it during renewal, but mid-policy changes are also allowed. It may affect your premium right away.

What’s a vanishing deductible, and how does it work?

A vanishing deductible is the amount that reduces over time if you drive safely and file no claims for accidents. Each accident-free year lowers your deductible, sometimes down to $0. It’s a reward built into your policy. While choosing a deductible, ask your insurer if they offer this sort of benefit.

What’s deductible recovery or subrogation?

Deductible recovery/subrogation is when your insurer pays your claim, then collects from the at-fault party’s insurer. If successful, you may get the deductible reimbursed. Generally, this may take up to six months. However, if both parties are cooperative in exchanging information, recovery is possible within one or two weeks.

Do you have to pay the auto deductible if you're not at fault?

Yes, if you file a claim under collision insurance, you will have to pay your deductible regardless of fault, or it might be subtracted from your final payout. However, in case of a liability insurance claim, you don’t have to pay any sort of deductible. It’s also important to note that if you’re not at fault and file a collision insurance claim, your insurer may try to recover the deductible amount (subrogation) from the fault party’s insurer. If they become successful, your deductible will be reimbursed later.

What happens if I can’t afford my deductible?

You can delay repairs, ask your mechanic for payment options, or get a small loan. Or you can ask directly to your insurance provider directly if there are any alternatives. Many insurers allow you to pay it from your claim settlement.

Can a car insurance deductible be waived?

Yes. In some cases. With a collision deductible waiver, or if your mechanic covers it. It depends on your policy, situation, and state laws.

Is it better to have a $500 deductible or $1000?

$500 costs more in premium but less out of pocket after a claim. $1,000 saves money monthly, but it means a higher risk when filing. So, you should choose what fits your budget and risk tolerance.

Is a $2000 deductible good for car insurance?

It can be, if you’re a low-risk driver with savings for emergencies. It lowers your premium but increases your financial responsibility after an accident.